Attorney Tom Brazier, a partner in the firm of Jones, LaMore, Brazier and Riddle, addressed the March 18, 2004 luncheon gathering of the CCCA with a look at a recent court case decision, and how investigation procedures and techniques affected the outcome.

In the case of Engelbrecht vs. Harry's Hofbrau, Brazier's firm represented the defendant. Much of his discussion focused on proper method and angles of photographing the scene of the claim. In this instance, he was able to show how pictures provided by the plaintiff, which were said to have been taken shortly following a purported slip and fall, were in fact taken much later. Close analysis of the photo revealed proof to contradict the claimant's sworn testimony.

Mr. Brazier utilized a multi-media approach in his talk, with photo charts and an AV slide presentation. He discussed at length the importance of thorough work in evidence gathering, including getting contact information for each person providing any kind of statement. He demonstrated the importance of quality photography, including some rather dramatic night photography examples.

"Take lots of photos," he said. "Film's cheap." Digital photography is now widely accepted in court, as well, he said.

While he urged claims people and investigators to take a lot of shots, he cautioned to keep in ming that "Every photo submitted to counself must be made available to the plaintiff".

CCCA member, Tom Shefchick, and electrical forensic engineer, added to the discussion the use of digital video. While it can be a valuable tool, Mr. Brazier again cautioned that whatever is submitted to counsel will be fair game to the plaintiff's side.

Tom Brazier's presentation was most informative. His detailed explanations of the viability of evidence was fascinating.

Good to see CCCA Past Presidents Rick Hilton (1982) and Arnie Dolence (1994) at the March meeting.